Friday, March 8, 2013

Harry Potter readalong 4:3

Hey, remember Nearly Headless Nick's Deathday Party, with the ghost orchestra, all of whom played the musical saw? ME EITHER, but it is such a hilarious detail, which is why I'm glad JK brought it up again in this book. If I'd made a joke that great, I'd be repeating it all the time.


Ok so a lot of you have been like, This is the first HP book that I had to WAIT for, so do you think that by this point in J-Ro's FAME her editor was scared to say stuff to her, and that's why this book is kind of draggy in sections and then also Harry will think things like, 'Really [some stage direction here] they were all right, really, dragons.'? REALLY WERE THEY REALLY ALRIGHT, HARRY?

Also, can we all agree that 'Bang-Ended Scoots' is WAAAAAY funnier than 'Blast-Ended Skrewts'?

We can.

Ok so where are we, plot-wise. AH YES, the Yule Ball. Why are there not more balls jokes in this section? Oh well, at least we have Dame Maggie Smith disapproving of everyone letting their hair down.


So Harry and Ron are trying to find theyselves some bitches. And bitches be everywhere! All 'giggling and whispering in the corridors,...shrieking with laughter as boys passed them,...excitedly comparing notes on what they were going to wear on Christmas night.' Bitches, amirite? All gossip and boys and clothes. COME ON, JK.

Ok but can we agree that the descriptive holiday bits are often WAY better than the plotty bits? Like the suits of armor that sing Christmas carols, but only know, like, half the words, and then Peeves hides in them and 'fill[s] in the gaps in the songs with lyrics of his own invention, all of which were very rude'? I mean, that's amazing.

Back to Harry and Ron. Ron finally ballses up enough to ask Hermione, but she's going with someone else and is all, 'Just because it's taken you three years to notice, Ron, doesn't mean no one else has spotted I'm a girl!' And I'm all like,


And then Malfoy is all mock-shocked that someone asked her, and then she's like, Oh hey, Professor Moody! And then M-foy freaks out and she's like, 'Twitchy little ferret, aren't you Malfoy?' and I am like, HERMIONE YOU ARE SO FEISTY LATELY. The club cannot even handle this girl right now.

And then they get to the ball and Ron's all, Where's Hermione? Where's Hermione? Was this whole section just all about R&H or is that the only thing I made notes on?

My priorities are just fine, Absurdly Young Ronald.

Oh and hey, if JK had had Hermione teach some hapless Bulgarian to pronounce her name properly in the FIRST book, there wouldn't be an entire generation of people who ALSO call her 'Hermy-own' whenever they aren't thinking straight.

Remember last week when Alice was like, The boys from Beauxbatons don't get much airtime, and I was like, IT IS AN ALL-GIRLS SCHOOL (that part may have been in my mind) but Parvati is all dancing with them and rendez-vousing in Hogsmeade so they do exist.

Let's talk about Rita Skeeter for a second. A lot of you hate her. I like her in THEORY, I think she could be a better character in FACT. Because she'll say things like, 'Disgraced Ex-Head of Magical Sports, Ludo Bagman...snappy start to a sentence' and I am like, NOPE. That is an adjective and then a noun. You need to work harder at your snappy starts. But REMEMBER WHEN HARRY CALLS HER A COW and then is like, Yikes, I am talking to the Headmaster, and Dumbles is like, 'I have gone temporarily deaf and haven't any idea what you just said, Harry.'

Excuse me while I dumble.

Oh, and D-dore's brother Aberforth 'was prosecuted for practicing inappropriate charms on a goat.' Wait, what? Is this what lonely wizards do in the country when there aren't any girls around?

Hey, there's still a Tournament going on! Hagrid: 'Yeh know what I'd love, Harry? I'd love yeh ter win, I really would.' First of all, no pressure. And secondly, THIS IS NOT NEWS.


Ok so Harry has this egg and he goes to the bath where, previously, Cedric had gone and mused on the question for '[a]ges and ages...nearly all the bubbles had gone.' DRRRRTY MYRRRRTLE.

Merpeople, bffs trapped underwater, Dobby and Gillyweed and Harry wades in to the lake and his 'sodden robes weighed him down' and seriously? Take them shit off, that is like trying to swim wrapped in a bed sheet. Harry gets there first (of course) but he's afraid to leave in case Krum etc don't make it so he hangs around HEROICALLY (of course) and then saves Ron AND the Little Le Fleur and as he approaches the surface, his Gillyweed gives out and 'water was flooding through his mouth into his lungs' and that is TECHNICALLY drowning but this was actually a really exciting challenge, so I'll let it slide.

On to the last section, which is where (if I remember) I start having some Serious Feels.


11 comments:

Sarah said...

Besides also trying to talk about books with people, I was TOTALLY all about boys and clothes in school. Teenage girls are so annoying! Well, so are the boys. I just don't like teenagers.

But I think you're on to something with her being super awesome at the descriptive stuff even when the plot is lacking sometimes. It's like she thinks up super amazing things in her head, like shifting staircases and amazing bathtub pools, to make up for those slightly boring parts.

Kayleigh Murphy said...

YES MY STAR TREK GIF IS SPREADING.

Hermione is so great. The twitchy ferret quote is like 'wait she can make jokes? Add 10, 000 points!'

And I'm too tipsy to comment further. I will be back.

Reading Rambo said...

Thanks for verifying that I am totally right. ALSO 'club can't handle it' joke. Always a winner.

WHERE DID YOU GET THAT LAST PICTURE THAT IS A TUMBLRY SORT OF THING

Red said...

I luuurve your recaps.

I love the holiday decorations and the suits of armor not quite knowing what to sing. Best details.

Aberforth was so doing untoward things to that goat. Even Rowling (semi) admitted that's what she was going for.

That last image: YUP.

Laura said...

"Bitches, amirite? All gossip and boys and clothes. COME ON, JK." COME ON JK indeed!

I totally thought that Beauxbatons was an all girls school too- maybe we were being totally sexist because that's the only reason they could have had a girl champion? I BLAME JK FOR THIS SOMEHOW.

Another awesome detail? The fairy lights that are made of actual fairies. I loves it.

Ashley said...

I am soooo glad I am not the only one confused about Beauxbatons' student body. I assumed that they were all-girls, but then I wondered where the French wizards go to school? It didn't help that the movies seemed to portray them as all-girls and Durmstrang as all-boys. (At least, I don't recall seeing BB boys or DS girls.)

mepamelia said...

Beauxbatons was an all girl school in the movie version and Durmstrang was an all boys school. This is the reason I hate that movie the mostest of all the HP movies. That movie is so completely sexist what with Fleur losing (because of course she was the only girl from an all girl school so she didn't even have to be better than a boy) + the way Hermione got boiled down to a date for a boy (no SPEW in the movie).
Argh!
I need to re-read my Harry Potters soon I think!

Jennifer said...

I think the descriptive, irrelevant side details are what make this series for me. Because Harry's obnoxious, everyone's a gender stereotypes, sometimes the "plots" don't make sense (see next week)...but the bits with grumpy Fat Lady and Peeves and whatnot - those are the BEST.

I have a feeling that everybody mispronouncing Hermione directly led to Hermione teaching Krum how to say her name in this book, and perhaps the entire addition of another culture. My friends and I used to get into wild debates about how to say her name.

Beauxbatons was depicted as all girls in the movie (and Durmstrang as all boys), which is why you think that. And why I thought that.

Finally (I apparently have a lot to say) I am STEALING your final image. By which I mean I shall start saying that and claiming originality.

Kayleigh said...

Her-moyne foreva.

A random observation for you: in the first movie, Harry exaggerates his blinking, like, a lot, I feel.

"NOPE. That is an adjective and then a noun." <haaaaahahahahahaha

Tasha B. said...

I seriously think about that Dumblin' gif on a daily basis now.

Michelle said...

About the musical saw orchestra:
Here is the HP theme played on a saw:
http://youtu.be/8h6oxopamGg
And this is what an orchestra of saws sounds like:
http://youtu.be/Idt3Okr4T5g