The first large chunk of this book is about sex. Not, like, has sex in it, but is loudly and cheerfully and without delicacy about sex and sexual awakenings and vaginas and so forth. I say this because about fifty pages in, I was all, Ok so this is a book I wouldn't recommend to my mother-in-law (for example). I mean, it was also about feminism and inequality and the injustice of it all, but it was mostly Moran's feelings about her lady-garden and the pruning thereof.
But also? It is HILARIOUS. I was literally weeping with laughter. I've dog-eared this one page and I can't remember if the bit I found noteworthy was the bit about how the bra is the rudest undergarment in a woman's arsenal (which you can test by tossing one at a nine-year-old boy, who 'will run, screaming, away from you - he cannot handle the rudeness of bras') or the bit about how making us feel bad about our breasts is the patriarchy's hobby. Because now, looking back, I am laughing at BOTH those things.
Queen V adores the rudeness of bras.
Ok so. Moran's lady-manifesto moves chapter by chapter through her childhood and adolescence, with each chapter ('I start bleeding!' 'I need a bra!' 'I fall in love!') operating as a launching pad (ha! Pads.) for both anecdote and polemic. Because being a woman is still sort of horrible in a lot of ways. And I once read a book called Confessions of a Slacker Wife that sort of made that point but mostly in frustrating half-jokes that brought me nowhere. I already KNOW I'm doing all of the laundry, thanks. And at one point, Moran suggests that the best tactic is to point at the patriarchy and laugh, like it was some idiotic phase we were all going through, and that as long as we could be like, Isn't THIS stupid, and keep kicking against the goads while keeping our sense of humor, eventually gravity would take its course (she probably made some joke about boobs here, too).
Because she isn't just like, Ugh, inequality, right? UNEQUAL DIVISION OF HOUSEHOLD CHORES, AM I RIGHT, LADIES? She's like, Here are some helpful ways of thinking about this, and here is a civil and useful reaction when some sexism is happening to you, and here is a balls joke.
So that's good. I appreciate sage advice, especially when doled out with balls jokes. And I get that humor is a piebald horse, and there’s this bit on breastfeeding that has me HOWLING
with laughter, and as I’m reading it (and howling) I’m thinking, There’s going
to be a whole host of people for whom this is not funny in the least. Be they
men, or women who have never breastfed, or women who HAVE but for whom
breastfeeding is a sacred trust and a wondrous superpower and not
breathtakingly absurd (I mean, it’s those first two things, for sure, but it’s
also definitely that last thing). And I'm not saying that if you're a man or if you don't have kids, you won't laugh. It's just, if your funny bone is located elsewhere from MY funny bone, you might not enjoy these frolics.
Mrs Patmore would not.
A sampling, then. She's talking about how eating disorders are still the Secret Sin of the Sisterhood, and asking why women will 'happily boast-moan about spending too much ("....and then the bank manager took my credit card and CUT IT IN HALF WITH A SWORD!"), drinking too much ("...and then I took my shoe off and THREW IT OVER THE BUS STOP!"), and working too hard ("...so tired I fell asleep on the control panel, and when I woke up, I realized I'd PRESSED THE NUCLEAR LAUNCH BUTTON AGAIN!") but never, ever about eating too much?' You will have to read the book to find out.
I have often said that I can only take people's arguments seriously if they are also making me laugh, and while that's not TOTALLY true, it's close enough to true for government work. Moran is wise and comforting and helpful for those times when you are just like, DAMMIT WORLD STOP PRESSURING ME ABOUT MY SHOE CHOICES. I dug this book with a shovel.
Eight and a half caterpillars!




8 comments:
You make this book sound amazing--I'm afraid there's not been a single other thing written about it that I have read that makes me want to read this book. Well played.
This has been on my TBR list for a while, now I must push it to the top of the list.
Thanks for the great review!
"Here are some helpful ways of thinking about this, and here is a civil and useful reaction when some sexism is happening to you, and here is a balls joke." - I feel like you perfectly summed up the book with this
I was intrigued to read this when it first came out, but I read one review in particular which really turned me off (here, if you're curious: http://earlynerdspecial.wordpress.com/2013/01/18/book-review-how-to-be-a-woman-by-caitlin-moran/) The idea that Moran ignores intersectionality and is almost exclusively white and cis-gendered kind of rubs me the wrong way.
But I'ma get off my soapbox now. This review is hilarious (as always) and this book does sound pretty funny, notwithstanding the stuff I said above.
One thing that helped me get through/over/around the above-mentioned intersectionality/white/cisgendered issues was that I pretended the book was titled "How to be Caitlin Moran." That she purports to tell every woman how to DO WOMANHOOD is silly. But if you look at it as "this is how *I* do womanhood," I think it's a lot more enjoyable.
Ohhhh, wait, there are people who WOULDN'T find HTBAW hilarious? Madness! But yeah, I heart this and I'm glad you did tooooo
Hm. I'm pretty sure if you threw a pair of boxers at a nine-year-old girl, she'd run away screaming, too. Then her mother would call the police and you'd be put on the sex offenders registry, and then you'd have to relocate to a house X feet away from elementary schools, public parks, and families with children and report your every move to the state.
But only if you're male, of course. If you're female, throwing your underwear at young boys is hilarious. You also get to make men feel bad about the length of their penises and hold them responsible for the behavior of people who also had penises 100 years ago.
Yup. Teh Patriarchy is so unjust.
Okay, i'll give it another shot. I got through the first sex chapter but haven't made it much past that. What I've read has been amusing but she's no UK-Tina Fey, which is what I was pitched.
Post a Comment