Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Mindless Eating: Why We Eat More Than We Think - Brian Wansink, Ph D

In her book Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me, Mindy Kaling is all, I love diet books, and I am like WOMAN I HEAR YOU. There's something about them. I mean, I love gratuitous eating, but I also love rigidity and structure and being told what to do. Diet books are like EAT THIS and I am like OKAY and then two weeks later I'm back in the King Dongs and I like being this way. Don't judge me.

Anywert, this is not a diet book. This is about the psychology of eating ('psychology of anything' being my other favorite topic), and about how to eat only what you WANT to eat, and I strongly approve this message. Because I don't like the idea that packaging and lighting can trick me into eating more gas station hand pies than I plan to. I'm totally fine with eating six as long as I WANTED to eat six.

Science likes to tell us how often we do things, like swallow spiders in our sleep, and according to Science, we make 200ish food decisions a day, which is a lot, so mostly we automate those decisions and thanks to our cavemen-brains our autodecisions are calculated to see us through the sort of calorie-deficient winter we are unlikely to bump up against ('we' being us first-worldians. All my third-world readers, eat whatever youalls can get your hands on and hey, good work on having the internet!). Even in this, the Land Of Plentiful Fats, the lizard-brain says MOAR FATS, and the mouth is like WORD.

And the real danger isn't in the turkey dinner, because we look at our ruined plate and think, I may have over-done it, I will now eat a salad. The danger lies in the mindless margin, those extra fifteen chips, that extra cookie, the extra eighteen handfuls of popcorn we didn't realize we were eating because the size of our popcorn bag and the sounds of popcorn around us and the fact that we're at a movie all says to us, Eat thusly, and thusly we eat.


The book is full of Experiments (as Science is wont to be) and the basic theme running through the Experiments is that we think we eat what we eat in the amounts that we eat ON PURPOSE, but that given a tall glass and a short glass, we will all pour more calorific beverage into a short glass because our brains our defective like that. Therefore we should replace all the short glasses in our houses with tall glasses. Automatic less-juice-drinking with no effort! Because the easiest diet to follow is the one you don't know you're on.

And the brain is a tricksy beast that cares not for nutritional information and serving sizes. Wansink asks, 'When you go to a "healthy" restaurant, do you pay attention to what you eat, or do you eat with abandon because you think it's generally healthy' and yes, when I go to Subway (which I STILL DO despite how off-putting those $5 footlong commercials are) I'm all, Subway = fresh veggies and Jared and therefore HEALTH so I will have the WHATEVER and I will have CHEESE MELTED ON IT POR FAVOR. This is why I don't bring low-fat or sugar-free anything into my house, both because LIFE IS TOO SHORT and because I will see those and think, These fat-free cookies are less bad actively good for me. It's a sick mind that sees 'low-fat' and thinks 'therefore some sort of vegetable' and that mind lives in my head-case.

And Wansink is no Mary Roach or Bill Bryson, but non-fic doesn't always have to be SOOER AMUSING to crank my chain. In fact, the few times Wansink goes for the hilarious! joke! it falls supah-flat. But the rest is delightfully informal and readable as hayull. Each chapter is A Way In Which Environment And Habit And Things Trump Willpower, and then an Action Step to deploy that in your healtheating favor. So even if reorganizing your eating habits isn't on your to-do, this is still fascinating shit.

Also, by the end of the book, when a study's subject is all, Of course I judge when to stop eating by my level of fullness, you can be all HO HO NO YOU DO NOT and you can feel so very smug. And then eat a sleeve of Thin Mints right through to the end because I Have Reached The End Of The Sleeve is a more assertive force than I Am Sated.

Fascinating and also practical! I dig. Eight and a half caterpillars.

12 comments:

  1. I just read and reviewed this recently - though your review is mucho better than mine - and quite enjoyed it too!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I saw Wansink give a keynote address at a conference recently, and I love that you said his jokes fell flat in the book, because they definitely fell flat in real life too. He made a joke about kids who ride "the short bus" to a room full of psychologists. He was the only one laughing at that one...

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's ok if his book isn't amusing, cause your review definitely is! Also I am intrigued by this book, and I want to read it so I can better understand my there-are-two-left-and-if-I-only-eat-one-one-will-be-lonely syndrome.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Last year, for the very first time in my life (why I didn't do this sooner I don't know) I started keeping track of the books I read. Mindless eating is on that list as well as Bryson and Roach, so right now I'm feeling the synchronicity of Raych-ness in my life.

    Which sounds really creepy and stalker-ish, now that I type it. Let's try again: you and I have similar tastes. I like that.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think you should write an eating psychology book. Just a thought.

    But seriously I am sitting here nodding my head. He is right. Just for fun (ha) I count everything that goes in my mouth. I'm trying to win a battle against mom jeans. And once in awhile I will slip and pop something in my mouth...the half Pop-Tart my son didn't eat, or those thin mints. Then I go and look at how many calories that was, and OMG. Insane. I just blew my entire day's goal with that one little slip. But I WANTED them, so how could it be wrong!? In sum, I can see why I was pushing maximum density at the end of 2011. It was all very subtle.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Having eaten to the end of sleeve just yesterday (and I started at the beginning of the aforementioned sleeve), methinks I need this.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I do this with Ben and Jerry's. I eat whilst watching the TV and then realized I've reached the bottom before I know it. Eep! So many calories. I saw Amanda's post on this too and the combined push is adding it to my TBR.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Reading this review made me want to eat something...I don't think that's how it is supposed to work :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. I can barely read this through the cookie crumbs flying out of my mouth right now.

    ReplyDelete
  10. oooh yummy!
    Pringles and Ginger Ale for dinner tonight. Blush.

    ReplyDelete
  11. "Because the easiest diet to follow is the one you don't know you're on." Bahaha, it's true! Between your review and Amanda's, I think I need to read this.

    ReplyDelete
  12. "It's a sick mind that sees 'low-fat' and thinks 'therefore some sort of vegetable' and that mind lives in my head-case. "
    Oh lordy, that's funny.

    ReplyDelete

Opinions! You have some. Give them here.