THIS IS WHY YOU EXIST, bookbloggopipes. This is your raison for être, to bring books like this to my face. Because the cover looks like Gossip Girl Goes to Amishtown and 'Franny Billingsley' sounds like a poor man's Maeve Binchy. (Whom I've never read. And whom, let's be honest, I'd probably enjoy, as I am rapidly becoming my mother.)
But come with me to page one, paragraph one, sentence etc. 'I've confessed to everything and I'd like to be hanged.' Punch! KaPOW! I asked for more this, and Universe? You delivered. (Now I would please like some salt water taffys.)
And Chime carries on in this dramatic vein. Briony's dead stepmother may or may not have killed herself, and her identical twin Rose (with her identical porcelain face) is Not All There and given to fits and that may or may not be Briony's fault. For Briony, you know, is a witch. And witches are hunted in the Swampsea, alas, so Briony must keep her witchy face hidden behind her perfect one, even when she meets a handsome, leonine stranger and yes there is romancey bits but this is like that one dish where I LIKE the cilantro and see how the cilantro adds to and improves the dish instead of being like WHY YOU THROW CILANTRO IN EVERYTHING?!? Plus the cilantro doesn't feel like it's inexorably fated to be together despite having just met and none of the other ingredients sneak in through the window to watch the cilantro sleep.
So that. And there are Secrets and faerie beasties and OH SO MANY SAVORY LIES! Very rarely does portentous live up to itself without being a little wtf, but Billingsley's unspooling is both sensible and sensational, both Of course and Holy shitsters.
And both the Smugglers mentioned that the prose took them some time to get into, but those two are loons because I wasn't three pages in before I was like, What ho, self! You are going to enjoy this! And that is a marvellous lucky place to be in three pages from the beginning, rather than three pages from the end when you only realize your enjoyment in retrospect. You know I love a plotty plot but Briony could have been TOTALLY NON-DAMAGED AND ALSO NOT A WITCH AND LIVING IN, LIKE, DELAWARE OR SOMETHING and I would still be like, Yes? Go on...? More dry and wry and unimpeachably honest but sneakily unreliable narration, please. More 'How has Rose lived for seventeen years and no one has ever killed her, not once?' Briony, you simultaneously slay me and break my heart.
My library has no other Billingsleys. I may go throw myself off a bridge now. Why are so many shitty novels serialized, and THIS IS THE ONLY ONE OF ITSELF? I will never understand you, Universe. (But thanks again for the stomping first lines. And don't forget about the taffys.)
Nine caterpillars.
Thursday, September 1, 2011
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)



Really good question on the bit about why some crappy novels are rehashed in serial form while great ones just stand alone. Sigh.
ReplyDeleteIf you want dramatic dramaticness in the first few pages, you should totally read THE SECRET HISTORY. Which I'm reading now and I thought it would be douchey and pretentious but it's all MURDER, plus some ancient Greek.
ReplyDeleteRAYCH, this is like, one of my top reads of 2011, almost THE MOST FAVOURITEST. and it is so goooooooood so gooooood, I agree. I loved that you loved it so much.
ReplyDeleteNow you must go and get The Folk Keeper as well, cause it is awesome (although not as awesome as this one).
Love this review.. how could someone NOT go out and buy this book after reading what you thought of it?! :)
ReplyDeleteNormally this is the type of book I would pass over, but after your review I think I will have to give it a try. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeleteCan't say I would have ever grabbed this one, but you've definitely won me over with your descriptions, tales of witches and idea that it should be given a sequel!
ReplyDeleteYou manage to make the most peculiar books sound irrestitable!
ReplyDeleteThis was such a good read! I'm glad to hear that you enjoyed it so much and I find that I'm a sucker for unreliable narration. Great review!
ReplyDelete