Wednesday, April 1, 2009

The Boy in the Striped Pajamas - John Boyne

I know. I know! I've become that guy who's always in your comments, all Ur blog sux! Then stop. Reading. It.
.
So, I don't really like YA, which is probably not news to you. I think I do, but I also think I like going to the gym when I kind of hate sweating (who knew?). I'm always picking up books because they look winsome, and then loving everything except that niggling je ne sais quois that makes all YA a bit dingy for me. It's like not being able to describe that flavor you hate (grated soap? Hiking socks) that ruins everything, except with flavors I know it's cilantro and I can ask the waiter to leave it out. With books, I can't even put my finger on it, so I'm going to call it the Young Adult Complex and start diagnosing books on a sliding scale. The Boy in the Striped Pajamas has a fairly mild case - far from fatal, but somewhat hampering quality of life.
.
On the other hand, it also has a hefty load of Tragic Ending, and I have got some serious whatever-shadenfreude's-non-sadistic-cousin is. Melancholy, in the old-fashioned sense? I appreciate a good Tragic Ending, and hate when cop-out epilogues bring beloved characters back to life just to appease people. Are we still talking about Striped Pajamas? What time is it, and where are my pants? *gets off soapbox*
.
SO! I can never find time for movies, and books fit better into the day's small cracks, so I picked this up rather than go check out the film. The inside flap is all, We're not going to tell you about the plot of this book because we think you should just read it. Clever ploy, Inside Flap, but I am about to thwart you. TBitSP is about a wee Churman laddie who moves with his family to just outside of Auschwitz so his Herr Father can be Herr Kommandant. The wee laddie takes to patrolling the outer limits of the fence, and strikes up a friendship with a skinny, bald-headed boy on the other side.
.
And you know it's not going to end well. Point me to one Holocaust book that ends in hugs and margaritas, and I will buy you a Facebook Beer. But the thing is, the way in which it doesn't end well will bitch-slap you. So brace yourself.
.
And there are books that I'm looking forward to reading to my chilluns because I love them now/loved them once but am now too old to find Little Bear mentally stimulating, and then there are books that I'd read to my kids because they would feel nice on the tongue, and they have a Stimulating Message. This is the latterer. It has those quaint repetitive bits that an author like Lemony Snicket does so well, and that make reading aloud worth doing. It's also a decent Intro to Man's Inhumanity to Man without being too horrific. So, future considerations, I guess.
.
Seven caterpillars for now.

9 comments:

  1. This one seems to be making the rounds right now and I'm not sure why. I haven't read it, but it just doesn't look interesting to me.

    Thanks for the review though!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Ha ha, when you were writing about flavors, I was thinking, "Uh, duh, it's always the cilantro!!" and then you said it, and now I know that we're meant to be together forever.
    Yuppo.
    Call me.
    September

    ReplyDelete
  3. Only you can make someone laugh while reading a review about a Holocaust book...

    ReplyDelete
  4. When I saw that you read this I was really hesitant to read your review because I thought your were going to tear it apart! The movie is fantastic!! I really want to buy it for my media library. One of the best adapted movies from book that I've ever seen.

    ReplyDelete
  5. it's like you took the past couple books from my TBR pile and then read them...I'm up in the air about YA. Sometimes I can take it, but overall I just don't read enough of it to have an overall opinion. And any YA that I do read, I go into knowing it's going to be total fluff so I don't expect much from it...but this one may be different since it's holocaust-related.

    ReplyDelete
  6. All good points but this is NOT a YA! At least I don't consider it one. It's for children, not young adults. The author has made a big effort to use a language that talks to kids and I think that's why it failed.
    The reason why it became such a huge bestsellers for adults to is something I will never understand:P

    ReplyDelete
  7. I haven't read this book yet but it is on a list of those that I want to read. Enjoyable review...glad you took it easy on this one!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I have a huge problem with YA books that feel then need to be weighty because they are for teenagers and everyone knows that teenagers are dealing with issues vs. good stories that happen to be written for teenagers. I generally dislike the former (but not as much as I dislike sterotypical Oprah books which are weighty and about women with issues because they must be, but are several hundred pages longer than your average YA issue book), but the latter can be wonderful (books by Madeleine L'Engle and Robin McKinley immediately come to mind).

    ReplyDelete
  9. I don't know if Number the Stars counts as a Holocaust book, but it more or less ends with hugs and margaritas...

    But I don't like Holocaust books much either.

    ReplyDelete

Opinions! You have some. Give them here.